RS (rainbowstevie) wrote,
RS
rainbowstevie

Five Great YA Novel Adapations + Five That Should Exist

EDIT: I never finished this in time to link it up to the main post... but I still want to share it.

This week's TTT topic is "Page to Screen Freebie," so my contributing post stems from a draft I wrote back in August and never finished/posted.


There was a Goodreads blog post called "31 adaptations that prove Hollywood loves YA," and I was like, "Well, this will make me furious." Clicking to test my hypothesis gave me a lot of 'I've had enough of this dude' re: David Levithan and John Green, and if there is a difference between Divergent and The Mortal Instruments I can't remember it), so for this topic, I thought it would be fun to highlight a rare few Hollywood got right, plus a few I think they are sleeping on big-time.

Side notes: I am avoiding The Big Franchises in order to highlight less-talked-about stuff here.

1. I Am Number Four
OK, I didn't actually read the book, but that's because it looked so boring that Dianna Agron is the sole reason I watched the movie, and it turned out ever so much better than it had a right to be given its premise. I am still steamed that it flopped at the box office and got zero sequels.

2. Miss Peregrine's Home For Peculiar Chilren
Loved the book. Loved the movie so much I barely noticed the changes made. Apparently this puts me in the minority? (p.s. still can't believe someone finally edited a trilogy down to a single movie and it's the ONE TIME I've read the trilogy)

3. The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
Great book. Greater movie. I wish so much that major studios would adapt more of the "realistic YA novels starring a girl(s)" books that I so love and maybe not cast Chloe Grace Moretz in all of them. They truly found magic with this cast.

4. The Princess Diaries
I do not have quite the same love for the book or movie that many of my generation do, but it is pretty awesome. I have to say, I might even prefer the movie.

5. Tiger Eyes
A very recent rave, and not exactly a box office hit, but for the sheer amount it improved on the book and brought the story to life, I got very attached to it. Also, it is not too often that authors get this much control over a production of their work -- it's basically a co-production between Judy Blume and her son.
-----------------------
BOOKS I WISH WOULD BE ADAPTED

1. Eleanor and Park - Rainbow Rowell
I would take almost anything of Rainbow Rowell's, honestly, but this is the one I think would translate best to the screen, as long as you find a dashing enough Park. Fangirl feels like it relies on the power of imagination (how would you work in her fanfic scenes?) and Attachments similarly relies on the formatting; IDC about Simon Snow; and I have no interest in Landline. So this is the one I want.

2. A Great and Terrible Beauty - Libba Bray
This is more dollsome's champion than mine given that I can't even remember anything that happens, but her enthusiasm is infectious. It's a period piece, it's magic, it's rife for rich visuals on a screen!! And it was popular when it was released, too; HOW DID IT NEVER GET MADE.

3. These Shallow Graves - Jennifer Donnelly
Speaking of rich visuals in period pieces! Although realistically, I pretty much read this on purpose as a YA version of What The Dead Leave Behind, so I'd want that one more.

4. Since You've Been Gone - Morgan Matson
It's my least favorite novel, but my absolute favorite cover, and I just feel like screen magic could really make both the best-friendship and the new friendships/romance "pop." Also I feel like it goes without saying I would take absolutely any Matson adaptation. COME ON, it would be such a good summer movie!

5. Just One Day/Just One Year - Gayle Forman
This is BEGGING to be brought to life on the big screen. I feel like if I could see the chemistry between the leads, I would believe they were star-crossed and would hate their gross stranger hookup less.

Tags: top ten tuesday
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments